Day 261 – Is Clear Intent Better Than Good Intent?

I have been working on this theory for a while now: clear intent is better than good intent. I am not completely confident in this idea yet, but I’ve been realizing lately that what one person thinks is good may not necessarily be good for others, or even most others. This seems like a relative concept, which I generally disdain. I never excuse bad behavior by claiming its perception is relative. I am also quite convinced that truth exists regardless of what humans want the truth to be. Just because we want something to be true does not make it so.

However, in this particular theory, good intent is effectively the desire for a person to change, manipulate, or direct a situation down a particular path because they feel it is the right thing to do. Thus, the desires of one person to do good or influence others to do good are susceptible to relativity.

Setting aside philosophical considerations of independent truth for this exploration, intent becomes highly subject to the whims of the influencer. This begs the question—which is better: the supposed good intent of the influencer or the clarity of what the influencer is trying to accomplish? This theory was recently put to the test during a leadership strategy meeting where several people were asked to divulge their intent. It wasn’t labeled as intent, but that is exactly what it was. Interestingly, in many cases, leaders had the same intent, but in several others, their intents were diametrically opposed. All these individuals were well-intentioned, believing their intent was right, yet in certain areas, harmony was lacking. It seems to me that rather than having leaders exert influence covertly, openly discussing and revealing their intent yields a much better outcome. Don’t misunderstand me: doing good is important, but doing good with the full understanding of those you work with or serve is infinitely better. At the end of the day, the good you believe you are pushing for may not be the best for others; it’s essential to find out.

A few years ago, I debated the ethics of censorship, another worthwhile test of this theory. The individual I debated advocated actively censoring social media. I cannot disclose the person’s or organization’s name. The individual was adamant about their responsibility to limit, restrict, and even edit opinions they deemed inappropriate. Initially, I assumed they meant restricting actions like yelling “fire” in a crowded theater, but it turned out they advocated curtailing opinions contrary to their perception of the public good. While I defend a company’s right to manage its platform as it sees fit, this instance involved a single employee asserting personal influence. My theory was applicable here: this person thought they were doing good by silencing dissenting opinions but failed to realize many others viewed such clandestine censorship as wrong. After discussion, we agreed it was best to openly voice and circulate this intent. Clarity of intent was necessary to evaluate whether the original intent was genuinely good.

This brings me to another consideration: perhaps clarifying your intent is the best action because you might discover your original intent is misguided. Good intent informed solely by your perspective and the bubble you live in can be problematic. For instance, someone from an affluent area observes a homeless person shoplifting a candy bar from a convenience store. Outraged, they exert influence to pass sweeping legislation with heavy punishments, aiming to prevent judicial diversion and increase penalties. They feel accomplished, believing they’ve done good. However, they fail to consider the impact on less affluent communities with significant homeless populations. Crime statistics spike, courts clog, and systems become overwhelmed. Their “good” intent inadvertently causes substantial harm. Clearly voicing their intent and seeking other opinions might have uncovered better solutions. The time, energy, and money spent on sweeping legislation might have been more effectively used to address the root causes of homelessness directly. Unfortunately, such misguided well-intentioned actions frequently occur in society, causing unintended harm.

We often live under an “us versus them” mentality, frequently pushed by entities seeking mass appeal—corporations, well-funded social initiatives, or political parties. Someone recently mentioned the media promoting the red versus blue concept, pitting us against each other. I questioned whether this accurately depicted reality. In fact, two political parties raise billions of dollars and spend it on media, making them two of the largest global advertisers. It’s no surprise we find ourselves entrenched in constant political dichotomy. I’ve often thought that if ten people were put in a room and prohibited from revealing political affiliations, they’d likely agree on many issues and quickly find reasonable solutions. There would be outliers, but generally, more consensus than conflict would emerge. The false assumption that “the other side” is irrational prevents us from revealing our intent, fearing exposure. This mindset is dangerous because we may actually be the ones in error, trapped in a false dichotomy and unaware due to our unwillingness to clarify our intent.

Although political examples illustrate this theory, its greatest relevance lies within organizations. When people come together, disagreements are inevitable. Two admirable individuals with good intentions may differ in approach, style, and methods. This is precisely why my theory is valid: if we believe our good intent is better hidden, we risk becoming adversaries with equally well-intentioned people. The same scenario playing out politically can happen in companies: two competent, well-intentioned professionals become at odds, each viewing the other as misguided.

This scenario is ineffective for any functional unit. Consequently, I increasingly believe that clarifying your intent is more important than believing your intent is inherently good.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Share the Post:

Recent Blogs

Day 3,239 – Your Minimum is Your Faith

This article explores the relationship between faith and the consistent effort we put towards our ambitions. It argues that the true measure of our belief isn’t in bursts of intense effort, but in the minimum we are willing to contribute daily, especially when motivation wanes. This daily minimum is presented as a practical expression of faith, demonstrating our commitment to a desired outcome even when results aren’t immediately visible.

Read More

Day 3,238 – Understanding Action Crisis

This article explores the psychological process of an “action crisis,” the moment when one shifts from believing they can accomplish something to recognizing they cannot. It delves into the journey of goal disengagement, highlighting the importance of knowing when to persist and when to let go, using examples like mountaineer Rob Hall.

Read More

Day 3,237 – Jedi Physiological Tricks

This article explores “Jedi Physiological Tricks”—simple, effective methods to influence your body and mind for better well-being. From using a warm blanket to soothe a distressed pet (or yourself) to leveraging bright light for morning alertness, these techniques tap into fundamental physiological responses. The author shares personal anecdotes, including calming his dog with a heated blanket and using a UV light to kickstart his day, highlighting how understanding and gently guiding your body’s natural systems can lead to improved comfort, sleep, and mental state.

Read More

Day 3,236 – Separating the Dream from The Decision

This article explores the phenomenon of becoming attached to an idea or dream, even when reality reveals it to be a bad fit. It uses the example of buying a car to illustrate how individuals can defend a flawed vision out of fear of losing the imagined future, rather than pursuing what is genuinely beneficial. The core message emphasizes the importance of separating the dream from the decision to protect one’s true goals.

Read More
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x