Day 3,238 – Understanding Action Crisis

This article explores the psychological process of an "action crisis," the moment when one shifts from believing they can accomplish something to recognizing they cannot. It delves into the journey of goal disengagement, highlighting the importance of knowing when to persist and when to let go, using examples like mountaineer Rob Hall.

A fascinating psychological process occurs when a person moves from believing they can accomplish something to recognizing they cannot. I have been here several times, both in physical challenges and mental ones. I have always had tremendous willpower and physical stamina. I have always believed that I can push through just about anything, until the moment I realize that I cannot.

We all have heard the story of Rob Hall by now. The famous New Zealand mountaineer and tour guide that died on Mt. Everest. I am not sure you will find anyone with more grit and determination than he had. Contrary to popular belief, shaped in part by movies and books, his demise was not caused by reckless behavior. I think, on closer inspection, it was his bold determination not to let one of his clients perish on the mountainside that led to his death from exposure. He would simply not give up until all was lost, and even then, I think he pressed on.

Yet, even this fearless adventurer reached a point where he knew that he had failed. This is memorialized in his last words to his wife, taken by radio from his team. He was comfortable and not suffering, a sure sign of severe hypothermia. He had stopped, knowing full well that it was the end for him. I have never been in a situation that tough, but I have been in a few where either the people I was with or I was at the end of the line, and I had to finally accept defeat. That is not easy for someone who prides themselves on their ability to punch through almost anything.

An action crisis is the moment, or more often the period, when your mind shifts from "How am I going to accomplish this?" to "Can I actually accomplish this at all?" This is a profound moment of crisis in the human mind. Before this point, you interpret obstacles as problems to solve. After this point, you begin interpreting those same obstacles as evidence that your goal may be unattainable. The eventual decision to release the goal is called goal disengagement. But I think the mental journey that gets you there is even more interesting.

A few times in my past, I have had to look a person square in the eyes and tell them that this is the end. The journey is over, and I am calling it. I recognize the soul’s unwillingness to give up, and in times of great crisis, someone needs to cut the process short, because you don’t have time to wait for people to come to the conclusion themselves. You can tell where someone is in the process; the pattern is always the same.

You encounter difficulty, and then you respond by trying harder. You become more determined; you tell yourself you need to keep pushing. Then you discover that even with this increased effort, it is not enough. You get frustrated, angry, and you even start to fight or deny the harsh reality in front of you. Then you come to a conclusion, and this is the moment when you start accepting that your resources, abilities, or circumstances needed to succeed are not there. You go through sadness, disappointment, and even grief. Finally, healthy people will then decide to release the commitment to the original goal and start to invest in a new one.

I think the critical moment is when your desire to achieve something finally becomes less influential than your assessment of reality. Consider the mountain climber. They have spent years preparing. They are within sight of the summit. Every part of their identity and ambition is telling them to continue. But their body is exhausted. The weather is deteriorating. The remaining daylight is insufficient. Eventually, something changes. They stop negotiating with reality. They realize the summit is no longer a reasonable objective under these conditions. This is an important distinction: Recognizing that you cannot accomplish something is not the same as losing your willingness to try. And it is not necessarily an accurate conclusion. Sometimes we underestimate our abilities and give up prematurely. Other times, continuing is genuinely dangerous or futile.

We spend a tremendous amount of time teaching people persistence, resilience, determination, and grit. We spend much less time teaching people how to recognize when persistence has become counterproductive. Yet these are two sides of the same skill: knowing when to keep going and knowing when to stop.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Share the Post:

Recent Blogs

Day 3,238 – Understanding Action Crisis

This article explores the psychological process of an “action crisis,” the moment when one shifts from believing they can accomplish something to recognizing they cannot. It delves into the journey of goal disengagement, highlighting the importance of knowing when to persist and when to let go, using examples like mountaineer Rob Hall.

Read More

Day 3,237 – Jedi Physiological Tricks

This article explores “Jedi Physiological Tricks”—simple, effective methods to influence your body and mind for better well-being. From using a warm blanket to soothe a distressed pet (or yourself) to leveraging bright light for morning alertness, these techniques tap into fundamental physiological responses. The author shares personal anecdotes, including calming his dog with a heated blanket and using a UV light to kickstart his day, highlighting how understanding and gently guiding your body’s natural systems can lead to improved comfort, sleep, and mental state.

Read More

Day 3,236 – Separating the Dream from The Decision

This article explores the phenomenon of becoming attached to an idea or dream, even when reality reveals it to be a bad fit. It uses the example of buying a car to illustrate how individuals can defend a flawed vision out of fear of losing the imagined future, rather than pursuing what is genuinely beneficial. The core message emphasizes the importance of separating the dream from the decision to protect one’s true goals.

Read More

Day 3,235 – Learning to Rest

The author reflects on the challenge of truly resting and recovering, often falling into the trap of using rest time for other productive tasks. They realize that associating satisfaction with accomplishment hinders their ability to genuinely rest, and propose that rest should be viewed as an intentional act of recovery, similar to an athlete’s training regimen. The key is to become as disciplined about resting as about working, scheduling and protecting recovery time.

Read More
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x