Day 175 – The Problem with Consensus

Consensus feels right because it signals fairness, inclusion, and alignment. But the mechanism of how consensus gets reached often systematically degrades the quality of the decision. When you aim for consensus, you are blending perspectives rather than choosing the best one. Bold ideas get watered down. Contradictions get smoothed over instead of resolved. You end up with the least objectionable option, not the most effective one.

You think you are lowering risk. You think you are shallowing up the areas where you could see large troughs, but at the same time you are filing down the peaks. In essence, this approach is flatlining the business. Think of the noise you hear in a hospital when the machine goes beep beep beep and then nothing.

Instead of seeking the best solution, you are coming up with what everyone can live with. Consensus optimizes for agreement, not truth or performance.

If you consistently do this, people in your organization will start to hold back dissent to avoid conflict. Pressure and groupthink will compromise your inputs. Consensus is almost never a true reflection of independent thinking. When everyone owns the decision, no one really owns it. This is a safe place for senior executives to hide. This leads to mediocrity by design.

Now, do not get me wrong. Consensus can be great, but that entirely depends on what you are working on. If you are coming up with a value statement, rules everyone must follow, and key principles of success, perhaps. However, for things like strategy, product decisions, high risk bets where you need judgment under uncertainty, uniform agreement will not get you there.

“Consensus is a coordination tool, not a decision-making tool.”

Consensus does not answer the key question: is this the right decision? It only tells you whether people can agree. Those are two different things entirely.

I have learned over time that to be successful you must separate input from decision. You encourage and embrace input, even when it is conflicting. You listen carefully. You consider the perspectives. Then you make the decision and you move fast. This preserves the value of diverse thinking without diluting the outcome. Someone must own the call. Someone must be willing to choose the path forward, knowing not everyone will agree, knowing the risk is real.

The next time you feel the pull toward consensus, pause. Ask yourself whether you are optimizing for comfort or for the right answer. Then gather the input you need, make the decision, and move.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Share the Post:

Recent Blogs

Day 3,241 – The Five Minute Accumulation

The author discusses the common habit of postponing small, five-minute tasks, which leads to an accumulation of unfinished work. This accumulation not only results in a larger, more time-consuming cleanup later but also creates a mental burden. The author concludes that consistently finishing tasks completely, including these small follow-up actions, is crucial for improving one’s life and avoiding overwhelming days.

Read More

Day 3,240 – Theory of Constraints

This article uses a personal anecdote about charging a non-Tesla EV at a Tesla Supercharger to illustrate the Theory of Constraints. It highlights how Tesla successfully addressed the charging infrastructure bottleneck for electric vehicles, while other manufacturers initially overlooked it. The author then applies this concept to personal lives, suggesting that identifying and addressing the true constraints is more effective than simply increasing effort.

Read More

Day 3,239 – Your Minimum is Your Faith

This article explores the relationship between faith and the consistent effort we put towards our ambitions. It argues that the true measure of our belief isn’t in bursts of intense effort, but in the minimum we are willing to contribute daily, especially when motivation wanes. This daily minimum is presented as a practical expression of faith, demonstrating our commitment to a desired outcome even when results aren’t immediately visible.

Read More

Day 3,238 – Understanding Action Crisis

This article explores the psychological process of an “action crisis,” the moment when one shifts from believing they can accomplish something to recognizing they cannot. It delves into the journey of goal disengagement, highlighting the importance of knowing when to persist and when to let go, using examples like mountaineer Rob Hall.

Read More
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x